Originally Posted by: Michael Monkhouse Sounds interesting. I bought the extended double CD cos it was cheap, but gave up after Restless. It was beyond boring and just repeated bits over and over. Sub-Razormaid.
Regarding
Complete Music , I understand what you mean about the version of
Restless. It sounds a bit tedious before the track even gets going (also my only complaint regarding the otherwise excellent
Nothing but a Fool, regardless of the mix). I much prefer the Extended 12" Mix of
Restless. It also ups the ratio of music-to-vocals (generally a plus on virtually ANY New Order track) but gets going right away.
The
CM mixes of
Singularity and
Plastic are absolutely much better than the stand
Music Complete versions. Especially
Plastic, as it's not just extended instrumentally, but rearranged (with the awkward bit tacked on at the end instead).
Tutti Frutti isn't really improved upon. It's just different (but are there not more lyrics? Not always a plus, as mentioned above).
People on the High Line, for me is also just different, not better. Extended and focused on synths more than the guitars. There's not really an Improvement on
Stray Dog, either. Just different synth flavours.
Academic is way too long. In theory, a more synthy makeover seems the obvious choice when remixing a track like that. But it reminds me of all those bands you hear about that supposedly "sound" like New Order, but don't really get it right.
The mixes (the original download has a different mix to that of the CD release) of
Nothing but a Fool are good, but take away good elements as much as they add. And the track was long enough already.
Unlearn this Hatred is a big improvement for me. I'm not keen on the isolation of the techno riff towards the start, but every other change is welcome. I love the ending with Chappy's bass part playing out and the final panning of the kick drum.
The Game also is improved on (music-to-vocals ratio, again a huge factor), turning a track I was lukewarm on into a worthwhile (if not unskippable) track.
Superheated is a weird one. I generally prefer the Extended mix from the download, but hate that the "You want your life back..." line is repeated. The remix on the CD version is odd because it amps up the synths, yet also reveals more guitar bits. Both mixes are a bit long so I generally stick with the original. Overall the song struck me (like the mix of Academic) as something the uninitiated think "sounds" like New Order. Slap some bouncy synths on. Job done. I had always assumed that the credits to Brandon Flowers were not just for additional lyrics, but for the somewhat generic, Hi-NRG style of the song. Was genuinely surprised when Stephen said it was Bernard's doing on the recent Listening Party. But, in case you never get that far into the Fritz von Runte mixes, his version of
Superheated is a mellow, piano version. It sounds like it would be a shit idea but it's great!
Edited by user 27 December 2020 15:06:22(UTC)
| Reason: typo