Originally Posted by: is it bro Originally Posted by: Salford Corner I'll whisper it, and I know some people will think I've been on the ale far too early, but overall, as an LP, I think it's superior to Brotherhood.
I'm not a huge fan of brotherhood personally, so your statement has the same effect as saying the new album is better than a Menswear album.
Is it better than GR or lowlife?
Loved Brotherhood when it came out, but these things always have a lot to do with your age at the time etc I think as well.
Listening to Bro'hood these days and I'm shocked at how weak the production is and I don't think it works as an LP overall either.
Expectations are involved as well, I was disappointed with GR because after such a long gap between LP's I was expecting far more, especially after hearing Crystal
as the first single.
Whilst with this one, my expectations were very low, I don't think it's as good as Lowlife, but it's not that far behind and it's a far superior LP to Republic and Siren's.
I think there are songs on this new LP that really are up there with their very best work and I think it's an LP that I'll be listening to in the coming years, six months
after Siren's came out and I wasn't listening to it at all and I've rarely heard it in it's entirety since.
So no, it can't really compete with PC&L or Technique, they remain my favourite LP's, with Low Life third and quite probably this new one just ahead of Brotherhood and Movement at the moment. I think some of these songs will work really well live too, Siren's songs really didn't translate very well in a live situation I don't think, they hardly put any in their sets when they were gigging after it was released either. The atmosphere around the band at the time of Siren's was truly terrible, wasn't surprised when they 'split' not long after. They couldn't have gone on like that, it was patently obvious two of them really weren't getting on, so I suppose this had a negative influence on the recording of the LP and the gigs. You can hear that it sounds like they enjoyed making this record, it's joyous and upbeat where WftSC was bland and downbeat.
Edited by user 24 September 2015 09:34:29(UTC)
| Reason: Not specified